KOSOVO (disputed status) |
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ |
Abandoning nationalist rhetoric and the zero-sum framing of the Dialogue is a critical condition for achieving a genuine normalisation of relations. While the Serbian government must not attempt to block the membership of Kosovo in international organisations, or to obstruct the functioning of Kosovo’s legal system by keeping control over the north, the government in Pristina must ensure a more substantial inclusion of ethnic Serbs, and foster a society based on the principles of equality and non-discrimination
(EUISS, April 2018: 'Belgrade and Pristina: lost in normalisation?') . |
|
(The Republic of) Kosovo wants to join the European Union. The EU operates comprehensive approval procedures that ensure new members are admitted only when they can demonstrate they will be able to play their part fully as members, namely by complying with all the EU's standards and rules, having the consent of the EU institutions and EU member states and having the consent of their citizens – as expressed through approval in their national parliament or by referendum.
The Treaty on the European Union states that any European country may apply for membership if it respects the democratic values of the EU and is committed to promoting them. The first step is for the country to meet the key criteria for accession. These were defined at the European Council in Copenhagen in 1993 and are hence referred to as 'Copenhagen criteria'. Countries wishing to join need to have: - stable institutions guaranteeing democracy, the rule of law, human rights and respect for and protection of minorities; The President of Kosovo, invited by the Dutch Institute for International Relations “Clingendael” held a lecture in The Hague on “Vision, challenges, and possibilities for Kosovo” in front of many state representatives, diplomats, journalists and representatives of the civil society. |
He said that The Hague is the place where Kosovo’s independence was legally confirmed by the International Court of Justice. He said that after this advising opinion in 2010, the political dialogue between Kosovo and Serbia started, which produced a historic agreement in Brussels, five years ago. “This happened after 100 years of conflict,” Thaci said. He added that The Hague is of course also the place where a part of the Kosovo justice system is currently established, by proving Kosovo’s readiness to always cooperate with the international justice.
“We are proud of our war for freedom and we have nothing to neither hide nor fear the truth. No one has ever tried to escape of hiding from justice, compare to the other countries in the region,” Thaci said. Speaking about the challenges of Kosovo, Thaci said the main one remains conclusion of the dialogue with Serbia. |
|
|
More trouble in Kosovo: Roadblocks ahead, The Economist Sep 14th 2011, 14:16 by T.J. | SILOVO AND ZVECAN
Unless something gives, Kosovo is set for a major clash on Friday. Roadblocks have gone up in the north of the country. Armoured convoys of NATO-led peacekeepers are heading for the north, along with black armoured vehicles belonging to the European Union’s police mission, EULEX. At the Serb-controlled barricade at the village of Rudare several lines of defence have been put in place: logs, tyres, gravel and pallets of bricks. At their head is a large picture of Vladimir Putin, Russia's Serbia-friendly prime minister. These developments are part of a long-simmering row over customs stamps. In July Kosovo's government sent special police units to seize the two border points with Serbia it didn't control. The Serbs, who reject the authority of Kosovo’s government in Pristina and predominate in the north, threw up barricades, thwarting the Kosovars. NATO-led peacekeepers took over the two crossings—but their mandate expires on Thursday. Some thought the problem had been settled. In EU-sponsored talks on September 3rd Serbia and Kosovo agreed a deal: Serbia would agree to accept goods from Kosovo stamped “Kosovo Customs”. (This wording is accepted by other countries that do not recognise Kosovo as a state, because the word “Republic” is absent.) |
But Kosovo's authorities then said they would deploy customs officers to the border crossings, supported by KFOR (NATO's peacekeeping force) and EULEX. Serbia's leaders responded that sending officials to the border had nothing to do with customs stamps. Petrit Selimi, Kosovo’s deputy foreign minister, wondered where customs officers were supposed to stamp goods, if not on the border. The issue could have serious political ramifications. On October 12th the European Commission will give its opinion on whether Serbia should become an official candidate for EU membership. If officials in Brussels believe that Serbia is not co-operating on Kosovo it is unlikely to get the green light. Serbia's government had hoped to win candidacy and take this triumph to the voters in early elections, perhaps next April. |
A sense of trepidation was palpable yesterday in northern Kosovo, as I visited two Kosovo Serb television stations. (Four such stations, in a project supported by IREX, are sharing programming under the umbrella name TV Mreza, giving Kosovo Serbs access to local news produced by local stations rather than the big Serbian channels in Belgrade.) In Zvecan, TV Most is housed in an old building overlooking part of the the sprawling and long-defunct Trepca mining and smelting complex. Serbian refugees from other parts of Kosovo live downstairs. Zvonko Miladinovic, who runs the station, says that its name—“most” means “bridge”—speaks for itself. “Our motto is to prepare our people for the future, to live together with Albanians,” he says. |
I am invited to give an interview. Cameras are shunted into position and begin rolling. A TV Most journalist asks me what I think of the situation. I choose my words carefully but she gets cross. The agreement on customs stamps was made between Pristina and Belgrade, I say; “nobody asked us,” she interjects. Serbs in the north won’t accept the customs deal, she says, because of the symbolism of having customs officers on a border with Serbia that they do not recognise. Mr Miladinovic agrees. “If the international community gave independence to the Kosovo Albanians," he asks, "does that mean they gave us as slaves to them? Can we decide on our own destiny?”
Although Kosovo's difficulties are concentrated in its north, only about a third of the country's 130,000 Serbs live there. The rest are in enclaves scattered over the centre and south of the country. In Silovo, near Gjilan (Albanian) or Gnjilane (Serbian), in the east of the country, I went to meet Nenad Milenkovic, head of TV Puls. There are some 40,000 Serbs in this region. Of the four linked stations only TV Puls is carried on a cable network that covers all of Kosovo. Things seem rather relaxed here. Next door a Kosovo Serb doctor, once a politician known for his hardline views, is treating a stream of Albanian patients. But the area is not trouble-free, says Mr Milenkovic, citing examples of alleged police violence. He also says that many Serbs suffer the theft of their cows. One of his problems is that Albanian companies don’t want to advertise on TV Puls “because many of them think they will lose their Albanians customers if they do.” As I leave, I walk past gaggles of teenagers on the street. Mr Milenkovic says that many of them, if not most, will leave Kosovo after graduating because there are no jobs. That is a problem that Serbs and Albanians share. But for the moment it is not on the agenda. |
This lecture was organized by ALB FACT (the Albanian Factor in South Eastern Europe) and in cooperation with NGIZ (Utrecht) and SIB (Utrecht).
SIB's read in information outlined: 'After Balkan wars of the 1990's, South Eastern Europe seems to be heading for a new era. Reconciliation and reconstruction were initial keywords. Security and stability followed next. Integration and participation are today's magical expressions. Obviously, one case differs from the other. That is exactly what the ALB FACT project seeks to demonstrate: while they may have certain factors in common, like the Albanian factor, each and every Balkan country is unique. |
Kosovo has seek ethnic polarisation and escalation to the extreme. Since NATO's Operation Allied Force (1999) conflict in Kosovo is over.
Looking beyond the standards & status stage; recognition issues and recent elections, a new situation comes to the fore: one of profound predictability. The question is whether we can already speak of stability, in light of pending issues both risks and opportunities. This revolves around some topical issues. For example: what is the status of the 'Belgrade' - Pristina dialogue? |
Are all communities in the Republic of Kosovo equally pleased with the current majority - minority situation? Is the future placed in parallel structures, or in developments like the 'North Mitrovica Initiative'? How will the new government move ahead? What are Kosovo perspectives for Euro-Atlantic integration? Is an international presence (EULEX/ICO/KFOR) still required and if so for how long? Is there also negative international interference and if so why?
Will the country continue to rely on remittance funds or will Foreign Direct Investments and emerging tourism be the answer to ensure peace and prosperity?
A paper 'Kosovo's new map of power: governance and crime in the wake of independence', |
dated May 2011 by Netherlands Institute of International Relations Clingendael gives a clear insight in the present state and progress.
In alsmost a full house the ambassador recalled the controversial as the 3 years of independence and figured out countries and supranational institutions that did recognized the independence: NATO, G8, Council of Europe, EU, OSCE. |
While Serbia's sovereignty is recognised by the international community, in practice Serbian governance towards Kosovo was virtually non-existent (see Constitutional status of Kosovo, accordance with international law of the unilateral declaration of independence in respect of Kosovo, Advisory Opinion of 22 July 2010 ).
Kosovo is governed by the United Nations Mission (UNMIK), assisted by an EU-mission (EULEX) and the local Provisional Institutions of Self-Government, with security provided by the NATO-led Kosovo Force (KFOR). Economy Kosovo has one of the most under-developed economies in Europe. Despite substantial development subsidies from all Yugoslav republics, Kosovo was the poorest province of Yugoslavia. Additionally, over the course of the 1990s a blend of poor economic policies, international sanctions, poor external commerce and ethnic conflict severely damaged the economy.Kosovo's economy remains weak. After a jump in 2000 and 2001, growth in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was negative in 2002 and 2003 and is expected to be around 3 percent 2004-2005, with domestic sources of growth unable to compensate for the declining foreign assistance. Inflation is low, while the budget posted a deficit for the first time in 2004. Kosovo has high external deficits. In 2004, the deficit of the balance of goods and services was close to 70 percent of GDP. Remittances from Kosovars living abroad accounts for an estimated 13 percent of GDP, and foreign assistance for around 34 percent of GDP. Most economic development since 1999 has taken place in the trade, retail and the construction sectors. The private sector that has emerged since 1999 is mainly small-scale. The industrial sector remains weak and the electric power supply remains unreliable, acting as a key constraint. Unemployment remains pervasive, at around 40-50% of the labor force.UNMIK introduced de-facto an external trade regime and customs administration on September 3, 1999 when it set customs border controls in Kosovo. All goods imported in Kosovo face a flat 10% customs duty fee. These taxes are collected from all Tax Collection Points installed at the borders of Kosovo, including those between Kosovo and Serbia. UNMIK and Kosovo institutions have signed Free Trade Agreements with Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Albania and Macedonia. FYR Macedonia is Kosovo's largest import and export market (averaging €220 million and €9 million, respectively), followed by Serbia-Montenegro (€111 million and €5 million), Germany and Turkey. The Euro is the official currency of Kosovo and used by UNMIK and the government bodies. The Serbian Dinar is used in the Serbian populated parts. The economy is hindered by Kosovo's still-unresolved international status, which has made it difficult to attract investment and loans. The province's economic weakness has produced a thriving black economy in which smuggled petrol, cigarettes and cement are major commodities. The prevalence of official corruption and the pervasive influence of organised crime gangs has caused serious concern internationally. The United Nations has made the fight against corruption and organised crime a high priority, pledging a "zero tolerance" approach. Culture and music has always been a part of the Albanian and Serbian culture. Although in Kosovo music is diverse (as it got mixed with the cultures of different regimes dominating in Kosovo), authentic Albanian music and Serbian music do still exist. The Albanian one is characterized by use of çiftelia (an authentic Albanian instrument), mandolin, mandola and percussion. In Kosovo, along with modern music, folk music is very popular. Classical music is also well known in Kosovo and has been taught at universities (at the University of Prishtina Faculty of Arts and the University of Priština at Kosovska Mitrovica Faculty of Arts) and several pre-college music schools. The modern music in Kosovo has its origin from the Western countries. The main modern genres include: Pop, Hip Hop, Rock and Jazz. Capital Priština. Official languages Albanian, Serbian, English. Ethnic groups (2007) 92% Albanians, 5.3% Serbs, 2.7% others. Former status:
Area total 10,887 km² / 4,203 sq mi. Population 2005 estimate 2.2 million. Currency Euro. The Serbian dinar is used in Serbian enclaves and North Kosovo. Kosovo is a region south Serbia which has been under United Nations administration since 1999. While Serbia's sovereignty is recognised by the international community, in practice Serbian governance in the province is virtually non-existent (see also Constitutional status of Kosovo). Kosovo is governed by the United Nations Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK) and the local Provisional Institutions of Self-Government, with security provided by the NATO-led Kosovo Force (KFOR). |
|
The Province of Kosovo borders Montenegro, Albania, and the Republic of Macedonia. It has a population of just over two million people, predominantly ethnic Albanians, with smaller populations of Serbs, Turks, Bosniaks, Romani people, and other ethnic groups.
The area is the subject of a long-running political and territorial dispute between the Serbian (and previously, the Yugoslav) government and Kosovo's largely ethnic-Albanian population. International negotiations began in 2006 to determine the final status of Kosovo.
History The last disputed region of the now defunct communist Yugoslavia, the province of Kosovo has an extensive and rich history. Inhabited by several different groups, it was initially (circa 1300 B.C.E.) inhabited by Illyrians, which eventually became incorporated into the Roman empire and subsequently the Byzantine empire. |
Ottoman Empire
The Ottomans brought Islamisation with them, particularly in towns, and later also created the Vilayet of Kosovo as one of the Ottoman territorial entities. Ottoman rule lasted for about 500 years, in which time the Ottomans were the absolute paramount power in the region. Many Christians adopted Islam, particularly many Bosnians and Albanians, whose populations became predominantly Islamic. The Ottomans administered through a millet system- based on religion- whereby Muslim subjects received more tax concessions and personal liberties compared to Christians and Jews. Kosovo was taken temporarily by the Austrian forces during the War of 1683–1699 with help of Serbs. After the Austrians retreated, many Serbs had to flee from Kosovo to evade Ottoman reprisals. In 1690, the Serbian Patriarch of Peć Arsenije III, who previously escaped a certain death, led 37,000 families from Kosovo, to evade Ottoman wrath. The people that followed him were mostly Serbs —but they were likely followed by Christians of other ethnic backgrounds. The Albanian people of the area also continued to intermittently struggle against occupation, yet suffered less reprisals at the hands of the Ottomans. Quite a few rose to prominence in the Turkish system, as administrators and as soldiers. During this time, many Albanians moved into Kosovo, filling in lands and houses vacated by fleeing Christians. Whilst relations between Serbs and Albanians were peaceful initially, this eventually deteriorated. At the outset, Christians and Muslim-converts celebrated each other's religious holidays together. However, later, many young Albanian Islamics participated in Turkish massacres of Christians, which in turn would be retaliated upon by the Serbs when they got the upper hand. This period has by many been identified as the catalyst of the subsequent deterioration of the relationship between Serbian and Albanian peoples. Apart from religious tensions, the subsequent political outlook changed for the two people. As the Ottoman empire began to collapse, Serbia aimed to re-incorporate Kosovo into the heart of its realm, whereas many Albanians were content with their new-found authority within the Ottoman system. With ongoing oppression from the Ottomans, migrations of Christian people out of Kosovo continued until the Ottoman empire finally collapsed. Many Serbs (and Vlachs) moved to Vojvodina and the Krajina region. Also, many of the minority of Albanians that remained Christian also migrated to towns in Dalmatia. |
|
Modern Era
During the 19th Century part of modern Kosovo was reintegrated in to 'Old Serbia' following a Peace Accord of 1878 which brought the cities of Priština and Kosovska Mitrovica under Serbian control whilst leaving the remainder of Kosovo under Ottoman authority. An ethnic-Albanian Prizren League was formed which sought to unite all of the Albanian provinces of the Ottoman Empire, but which was ultimately defeated by Ottoman forces. During the First Balkan War of 1912 most of Kosovo was retaken by the Kingdom of Serbia while the region of Metohija (know as the Dukagjini Valley to ethnic-Albanians) was taken by the Kingdom of Montenegro. Populations of ethnic Serbs and Albanians tended to shift following territorial conquests. During World War I, Kosovo was occupied by the Bulgarian and Austro-Hungarian forces following a serious defeat of Serbian and allied armies in 1915. Returning in 1918, the Serbian army pushed the central powers out of Kosovo as the war came to a close. Following WWI, the Kingdom of the Serbs, Croats and Slovenes was formed, bringing together Serbian Kosovo and Montenegrin Metohija within the new kingdom. The partition of Yugoslavia by the invading Axis Powers from 1941 and 1945 awarded most of the territory to the Italian-occupied Greater Albania, and a smaller part of it to German-occupied Serbia and Greater Bulgaria. Both wars were occasions for inter-ethnic violence and both voluntary and forced population shifts. Following the end of the war and the establishment of Tito's Communist regime, Kosovo was granted the status of an autonomous region of Yugoslavia in 1946 and became an autonomous province in 1963. With the passing of the 1974 Yugoslavia constitution, Kosovo gained self-government. Throughout the 1980s tensions between the Albanian and Serb communities in the province escalated. The Albanian community favoured greater autonomy for Kosovo, whilst Serbs favoured closer ties with the rest of Serbia. There was little appetite for unification with Albania itself, which was ruled by a Stalinist government and had considerably worse living standards than Kosovo. Beginning in March 1981, Kosovo Albanian students organized protests seeking that Kosovo become a republic within Yugoslavia. Those protests rapidly escalated into violent riots "involving 20,000 people in six cities" that were harshly contained by the Yugoslav government. |
Serbs living in Kosovo complained at discrimination from the provincial Kosovo government (run by the ethnic-Albanian dominated Communist Party of Kosovo) and neglect from the Federal authorities in Belgrade. In August 1987, during the dying days of Yugoslavia's Communist regime, Kosovo was visited by Slobodan Milošević, then a rising politician. Milošević capitalised on this discontent to consolidate his own position in Serbia. In a staged event, having drawn huge crowds to a rally commemorating the Battle of Kosovo, he pledged to Kosovo Serbs that "No one should dare to beat you", and became an instant hero of Kosovo's Serbs. By the end of the year Milošević was in control of the Serbian government.
In 1989, the autonomy of both Kosovo and of Vojvodina were drastically reduced by a new Serbian constitution which allowed a multi-party system, introduced freedom of speech and promoted human rights. Though later subverted by Milošević's abuses, the new constitution was a significant step forward from the previous Communist constitution. However, the new constitution also significantly reduced the rights of the two previously autonomous provinces, giving control of many areas directly to the Government of Serbia, including control of the police, the court system, the economy, the education system and language policies. Differing viewpoints see either an attempt to gain control of a crisis-ridden province or a cynical exploitation of nationalist politics. When called to ratify the new constitution in March 1989, the assemblies of the provinces were met with tanks and armoured cars, effectively forcing the delegates to accept the amendments. Kosovo Albanians boycotted state institutions and elections and established separate Albanian schools and political institutions. On July 2, 1990, an unofficial Kosovo parliament declared Kosovo independent, though this move was recognised only by Albania. In 1992, the parliament organised an unofficial referendum, observed by international organizations not recognized internationally, which saw a 98% vote of the Kosovo Albanian majority for independence. Kosovo War Under the leadership of Ibrahim Rugova, the Albanians in Kosovo conducted a peaceful resistance to Serb rule. In 1995, after the Dayton Agreement which ended the Bosnian War, but did not address Kosovo, many Albanians became disenchanted with Rugova's peaceful strategy. Consequently, the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) was formed in 1996 with the goal of attaining an independent Kosovo. Other KLA factions fought with the goal of uniting all the Albanian populated lands and some simply to defend Kosovo Albanians from Milosevic's regime, but they were joined together by the common objective of defeating what they saw as Serb oppressors. They employed guerilla-style tactics against Serbian police forces, paramilitaries and regular civilians. Violence escalated in a series of KLA attacks and Serbian reprisals into the year 1999, with increasing numbers of civilian victims. Some sources allege that western security forces and Al Qaeda both had roles in supporting the KLA. In 1998 the Yugoslav authorities were forced to sign a unilateral cease-fire and partial retreat. Under an agreement led by Richard Holbrooke, OSCE observers moved into Kosovo to monitor the ceasefire, while Yugoslav military forces partly pulled out of Kosovo; neither side kept the ceasefire fully. A massacre of Albanians by Serbian military at the town of Racak in January 1999 increased international concern at Milosevic's actions. The subsequent Rambouillet conference fell apart after Milosevic refused to sign an agreement which would give Kosovo equal status as a Republic and which purportedly would give NATO forces access rights to all of Yugoslavia. This triggered a 78-day NATO campaign in 1999. At first limited to military targets in Kosovo itself, the bombing campaign was soon extended to cover military or related targets that supported military troops all over Yugoslavia, including bridges, power stations, factories, broadcasting stations, the transportation network, and various government buildings. During the conflict roughly a million ethnic Albanians fled from Yugoslav forces or were forcefully driven by Yugoslav forces from Kosovo, several thousand were killed (the numbers and the ethnic distribution of the casualties are uncertain and highly disputed). An estimated 10,000 ethnic Albanians and 3,000 Serbs are believed to have been killed during the conflict. Some 3,000 people are still missing, of which 2,500 are Albanian, 400 Serbs and 100 Roma. Kosovo after the war The conflict ended with an agreement signed by both Yugoslavia and NATO at Kumanovo in Macedonia on 9 June 1999 and with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 which, whilst recognising Serbian sovereignty, authorised an international civil and military presence in Kosovo, placing it under interim UN administration with a NATO-led peacekeeping force (KFOR). With the withdrawal of Serb forces, ethnic-Albanian refugees began returning from Albania and the Republic of Macedonia. In fear of their safety, perhaps up to 250,000 Serbs and other ethnic minorities fled their homes north. Many displaced Serbs fear to return and around 120,000-150,000 Serbs remain in Kosovo, but remain in a difficult security and economic situation. In 2001, UNMIK promulgated a Constitutional Framework for Kosovo which established the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government (PISG), including an elected Kosovo Assembly, Presidency and office of Prime Minister. Kosovo held its first free, Kosovo-wide elections in late 2001 (municipal elections had been held the previous year). UNMIK oversaw the establishment of a professional, multi-ethnic Kosovo Police Service. In March 2004, Kosovo experienced its worst inter-ethnic violence since the Kosovo War. The unrest in 2004 was sparked by a drowning of Albanian children in the Ibar river. Unfortunately the cause of this event has not yet been determined. Taking advantage of the situation, numerous Albanian extremists in several locations in Kosovo burned Serbian houses, Serbian Orthodox Church sites (including some medieval churches and monasteries) and UN facilities. Huge mobs of hooligans purged several Serbian villages. Kosovo Police established a special investigation team to handle cases related to the 2004 unrest and according to Kosovo Judicial Council by the end of 2006 the 326 charges filed by municipal and district prosecutors for criminal offenses in connection with the unrest had resulted in 200 indictments: convictions in 134 cases, and courts acquitted eight and dismissed 28; 30 cases were pending. International prosecutors and judges handled the most sensitive cases. Kosovo status process International negotiations began in 2006 to determine the final status of Kosovo, as envisaged under UN Security Council Resolution 1244 which ended the Kosovo conflict of 1999. Whilst Serbia's continued sovereignty over Kosovo is recognised by the international community, a clear majority of the province's population would prefer independence. The UN-backed talks, lead by UN Special Envoy Martti Ahtisaari, began in February 2006. Whilst progress was made on technical matters, both parties remained diametrically opposed on the question of status itself. In February 2007, Ahtisaari delivered a draft status settlement proposal to leaders in Belgrade and Pristina, the basis for a draft UN Security Council Resolution which proposes 'supervised independence' for the province. As of early July 2007 a draft resolution, backed by the United States, the United Kingdom and other European members of the Security Council, had been rewritten four times to try to accommodate Russian concerns that such a resolution would undermine the principle of state sovereignty. Russia, which holds a veto in the Security Council as one of five permanent members, had stated that it would not support any resolution which was not acceptable to both Belgrade and Kosovo Albanians. Whilst most observers had, at the beginning of the talks, anticipated independence as the most likely outcome, others have suggested that a rapid resolution might not be preferable. 17 Februari 2008 Kosovo declared itself an independent state. |